Birds of Prey #9 Reviewed

My review includes spoilers - if you don't want to know what happens in this issue of Brids of Prey then stop reading now!

Birds of Prey #9

'The Death of Oracle' continues with the third instalment of this four-part story-arc. 'The Soul and the Sacrifice' opens with something of a surprise: Dinah 'Black Canary' Lance's late mother - Dinah Drake Lance - greeting her daughter from the headquarters of the JSA. When her mother asks why everything she loves dies and, as only a mother can, why she won't wear her hair differently, Dinah understandably becomes emotional.

Moments later she finds herself in the company of her father - her late father - who questions whether his "kitten" is eating properly. As father fades before her eyes mother reappears, reminding Dinah that her father had died a painful death and that she was nowhere to be found.

At this point tears are cascading down Dinah's cheeks.

Through appearances of Red Arrow Roy Harper and Green Arrow Oliver Queen, culminating in a vision of her 'daughter' Sin who, matter of fact, tells Dinah how very lonely she is we see that Dinah can take no more pain and we witness her curled up in a ball - her memories and thoughts finally having got the better of her.

Out of Dinah's mind and back into reality Batman - "The" Batman, Bruce Wayne - crouches over her while speaking with Oracle - Barbara Gordon - over the comms unit. Understanding the seriousness of the situation Barbara reminds Bruce that her friend is presently wanted for murder so taking her to somewhere as public as a hospital might not be such a good idea. Instructing him to bring her back to base - Kord Tower - Babs explains that any physical injuries Dinah may be suffering from are likely to be the least of their problems.

Enquiring about the rest of her team - Dawn Grainger, Dove; Helena Bertinelli, Huntress and Zinda Blake, Lady Blackhawk - Babs learns that they have all been captured by Calculator. Not exactly as planned ... but, by the same token, not a million miles away from it we suspect.

As Batman gathers-up Black Canary into his arms and takes flight back to Kord Tower the story cuts to a school bus hastily travelling through the otherwise deserted city streets. On board the bus Dawn, Helena and Zinda appear unharmed but have their hands bound. Looking on, one of their 'hosts' reminds the women that with an automatic weapon trained on them any aggressive moves would not be recommended.

Responding to Helena's jibes he reveals his name to be Current, one time partner "in the special effects business" of Bolt. As Zinda joins in with the understandably bad-natured conversation Current, aware that all three women will be carrying tracking devices, instructs one of his charges to search the women - "make it ... thorough" he says.

Taking this as her cue to lash out Zinda 'knees' the guard, only to be struck herself by the now-charged Charge. With blood dripping from the corner of her mouth Zinda warns her attacker of the consequences of striking her again. Her words seem to connect as Charge turns his back, walks away and instructs another of his crew that they are nearly at their destination - and if there's any more trouble from "the blonde" to let him know and he'll deal with her.

Back at Kord Tower Barbara has a surprise visitor: Hank Hall, Hawk - Avatar of War. His appearance is a surprise because, as Babs points out, he'd been untraceable for fully fifteen minutes earlier, and that *shouldn't* be possible. Hiding the fact that he'd paid a private visit to The Penguin's club Hawk asks for Dove's whereabouts.

"That's complicated" he's told.

As Barbara discovers she's now lost track of her three friends Batman arrives with Black Canary in his arms. Summoning Savant, his medical skills may be required, Barbara once again reminds herself that physically Dinah's fine, it's the effects of her very brief encounter with Mortis that's causing the problem.

Becoming ever more agitated with events Hawk starts hitting out at those around him - initially verbally to Barbara before turning and striking out at Bruce. Evading his initial blows Bruce doesn't appear to want to fight and before things can get too out of hand Barbara brings Hawk to the ground with a well placed strike of her baton before declaring that they will rescue Dove - along with Huntress and Lady Blackhawk - and then they'll talk about his attitude.

But first, she needs to be somewhere else.

As Barbara makes her exit the story returns to the turmoil inside Dinah's mind as Mortis, Goddess of the Forgotten Dead, once again plays wicked games with her memories. Taunted that her friends have abandoned her - again - Dinah appears at breaking point, rivers of tears streaming from her eyes. Despite appearances though Dinah is far from down and out as, summoning all of her mental strength, she rises to Mortis's challenges and declares that she won't be beaten.

Elsewhere in Gotham, Calculator, Mammoth, Current and their team of HIVE agents look on bemused as Mortis herself appears to be suffering from some sort of seizure. Realising that such involuntary actions likely mean that her "prey" must have found a way to set herself free he immediately returns his attention to his prisoners - Dawn, Helena and Zinda.

Explaining that he's only really interested in Oracle he turns his weapon on Zinda - she's no use to him. Before he can pull the trigger Dawn breaks free of her shackles and with a mighty 'Dove' cry disarms Calculator, evades an attack from Current and knocks Mammoth from his feet.

Turning her attention back to Calculator Dove momentarily discovers that he once again appears to hold the upper hand - Zinda Blake is again at his mercy. In a instance though the stakes are raised as an armoured helicopter rises into the air, sends a verbal warning before opening fire. As Calculator and his team take cover - and decide that the aircraft is being pilotted by Oracle - the Birds likewise make their way towards temporary safety.

Realising that this could be an opportunity, possibly his only opportunity, to rid himself of Oracle, Calculator instructs Current to take down the helicopter - by using, interestingly, just half of his usual power: presumably he doesn't want the aircraft and its pilot totally destroyed.

Moments later, with the Birds once again in the hands of their pursuers and the aircraft in flames, Calculator announces, with a broad, satisfied smile, that finally his pain "is completely gone".


I really enjoyed this book - and after nine issues of this series I'm very happy to be able to say that. After Birds of Prey burst back onto our pull-lists I've felt I've struggled at times to avoid using words like 'decent', 'solid', 'serviceable' (I hear that word used quite often to describe comics and I'm not really sure what it means!) - words that to me mean 'okay', 'good' even but certainly someway short of excellent.

This was an excellent issue.

I immediately warmed to Inaki Miranda's interior artwork - I thought it was among some of the best we've seen so far in the series. Likewise Gail Simone's writing was fantastic - and again I've not always felt able to say that about Birds of Prey this past year.

The cover art from Stanley 'Artgerm' Lau is stunning - in fact I think my biggest worry with Artgerm's covers is that my expectations are so high that inevitably I'm going to be disappointed: and yet issue after issue he delivers the goods!

When I saw a digital preview of the cover I wasn't, to be honest, particularly taken with it. Only now that I can hold the issue in my hands have I been able to truly appreciate it for all its beauty. Despite having much of her face covered the sense of shock and anguish that Huntress feels is clearly evident. Holding onto her friend Dinah, Black Canary, for strength it's Huntress, rather than anyone or anything else featured that's the focus of this cover for me. If I have just one criticism, it's that facially Black Canary and Lady Blackhawk look just a little too similar.

Gathered around an overturned, crumpled wheelchair we really get a feel for the individual strengths - and weaknesses - of the Birds.

In terms of the story I thought the strongest, stand out scenes were the dream - or more appropriately nightmare - sequences. Opening with Dinah coming face to face with her mother, her father, loved ones, and closing with her battle of mental strength with Mortis, I thought the story was perfectly framed. I found the opening pages really quite touching as Dinah came face to face with those ghosts from her past and I really did feel her pain as she found herself at the sharp end of some pretty blunt comments.

Credit equally to Inaki Miranda for adding to Dinah's vulnerabilities by portraying her, it occurred to me as a younger, less physically-confident woman than I'm used to seeing.

The 'war of minds' towards the very end of the book was similarly powerful I felt, as we witnessed Dinah teeter on the brink of a complete mental breakdown and, just as it looked like she was 'down and out', draw upon her inner strengths and fight back against her opponent.

As well as being the focus of the cover, for me Huntress's portrayal was a stand out feature of the book - particularly through her beautifully written inner monologue. As those around her were in danger of losing their heads Huntress - who I've often felt was very much a 'punch-now-ask-questions-later' character - was able to remain calm, mindful of the broader picture.

The scenes set a Kord Tower and featuring Oracle, Hawk and Batman were at the same time enjoyable to read and yet disappointing to look at. I enjoyed reading as Hank took out his frustration on those around him, and the respective responses from Oracle and Batman and yet at times the art on these few pages left me a little disappointed. I felt there were some inconsistencies in Barbara Gordon's appearance and at times Hank Hall's body shape didn't quite look right to me.

Those comments aside I reiterate that I thought the art was among some of the best we've seen so far - the beautiful 'pin-up' splash page that opened the issue, the look of absolute horror in Dinah's eyes throughout the opening pages, the depth and warmth that I sensed in pretty much every panel and some eye-catching, thought-provoking, imaginative page layouts.

I believe Inaki Miranda is solicited as the artist of the next issue of Birds of Prey and I'm looking forward to enjoying his work on this title and elsewhere.

In closing, this was a top-quality issue I thought - a pleasure to read from cover to cover - and I'm anxious to see how the story-arc concludes next month.

Birds of Prey #9
Written by Gail Simone, art by Inaki Miranda, colours by Nei Ruffino, letters by Dave Sharpe, cover by Stanley 'Artgerm' Lau
Published by DC Comics, April 2011

Birds of Prey #8 Reviewed

As always, my review includes spoilers - if you don't want to know what happens in this issue of Birds of Prey then stop reading now!

"The Death of Oracle" continues with the second part of this four-part story-arc entitled "The Gauntlets and the Guillotine". Having smashed their way into the nightclub where the Birds of Prey were enjoying a girls night out, Mortis - the self-proclaimed "Goddess of the Forgotten Dead" - accompanied by Mammoth and the "newbie" villain known as Current confronts the Birds demanding, for the final time they are told, to know which of them is Oracle.

Zinda Blake - Lady Blackhawk - steps forward to tackle Mortis and is immediately warned off by her opponent with the suggestion that with just a single touch of her hand others have been driven to suicide - and she could easily be next.

Not one to take kindly to being threatened Helena Bertinelli - Huntress - steps across her friends and into Mortis's line of sight ... "Try it" dares Helena as Mortis turns her attentions to Dinah - Black Canary.

Elsewhere, events in the club are being monitored by Calculator who's delighted that the information he paid Savant for looks like being accurate - and he reminds himself that he must, in turn, kill his one-time informant.

Across the city at Barbara Gordon's new high-tech, highly-secret base of operations in Kord Tower, Babs and Bruce Wayne - Oracle and Batman of course - are likewise following events. Babs reveals that while she's aware of Mammoth both Mortis and Current are new to her ... and as such causing her to be more than a little concerned.

Appreciating the scale of the situation Bruce offers a solution - he can intervene - which Babs immediately dismisses: the Birds of Prey are her team, her responsibility. Besides, Barbara reasons, her team, including as it does Black Canary and Huntress, can handle the situation can't they.

Can't they?

Returning to the nightclub and Mortis offers Dinah one last opportunity to cooperate before Dove - Dawn Grainger - steps in and, to my surprise, identifies herself as the ellusive Oracle. As events at the club unfold we cut across town where the aforementioned Calculator is now writhing in pain on the floor of his office - on the verge of a breakdown it seems: with no secret powers or costume to rely upon Calculator has always relied upon and prided himself on his intelligence, his brain - and now, thanks to Oracle he believes, his mind is failing him.

At Penguins Iceberg Lounge, which remains closed for repairs, we discover Oswald Cobblepot 'auditioning' new waiting staff and very quickly losing his patience with his new employees. As he takes his frustration out on one young woman he becomes aware that they have been joined by Hawk - the Avatar of War Hank Hall, who we learn has somehow managed to switch off his comms link connecting him to Oracle - demanding an audience with Penguin.

Apparently having something of a change of heart from their earlier conversation Barbara Gordon appears willing to enlist Batman's help but she has a feeling that her friend isn't going to like her idea - for the first time Batman will have to take a dive. This isn't the time, Babs reveals, to explain to Bruce what she has done to The Calculator ... she was vulnerable, Calculator knew her identity, so she took their fight into his mind and altered his memories.

As Calculator uses recognition software for details of Dove's background - the results of which I assume have been tampered with by Barbara to give false information - we return to the nightclub where, with the public apparently clear of the club, Babs finally gives the word for the Birds to engage their opponents - much to Dinah's relief and pleasure. With a single blow she knocks Mortis off her feet warning the others to be careful of her touch. With Mortis down, but certainly not out, the Birds turn their attention to both Current and Mammoth ... and their army of 'foot soldiers'.

Amidst all this violence Helena realises that the premises aren't, after all, free of members of the public as she discovers two women crouching under a table desperately trying to avoid getting caught up in the madness.

As Black Canary, now delighted to have been joined by Batman, does her best to keep the onslaught at bay Helena, with the help of Lady Blackhawk, usher the women towards safety.

With Mortis grounded, and Batman now part of his opposition, Current reveals to Calculator that he wants out - but Calculator is having none of it as he threatens his 'employee' that if he doesn't do as he's instructed he may just have to ask Mammoth to pay a visit to his girlfriend.

Reaching the outer ruined walls of the club Helena and Lady Blackhawk are relieved that they've managed to get the civilians to safety ... only to find themselves held captive at gunpoint.

Distracted by the events unfolding before her Black Canary fails to notice Mortis approaching from behind - as she removes her glove just one touch of her hand sends Dinah into a trance-like state: Barbara's words of warning to the group coming just too late.

With her friend and team-mate under threat and vulnerable Dove backs down and allows herself to be taken. As Mortis, Mammoth, Current and their men seize Dove and make their exit the "Goddess of the Forgotten Dead" reveals that once in a trance none of her victims ever come out of it ...

What can the future hold for the Birds of Prey, and particularly Black Canary?


This was another galloping Birds of Prey adventure from writer Gail Simone - pretty much every scene, except perhaps for those set at Kord Tower between Barbara and Bruce, had a sense of chaos and confusion about them as the story jumped around Gotham city at a rapid pace, but without ever feeling particularly rushed, rarely stopping anywhere for more than what seemed like a few minutes.

What at first appeared to me to be a fairly shallow story grew, with a second and third read, into something much more complex. Having finished reading the issue I find myself asking many questions that I'm now genuinely keen to answer.

The overarching question is, of course, just what is Barbara's plan? Through Savant she's set this confrontation up - I'm surprised she's chosen such a public venue - but to what end? Why is Dove passing herself off as Oracle? Of all the team members who amongst us would have chosen Dove for such a crucial and dangerous 'mission'? Batman's involvement may - just may! - have been initially unplanned but what part does he now play in Barbara's scheme and why ask him to take such a very public fall?

On a minor, fairly trivial point, I've appreciated the 'name tags' that have appreared throughout this series: identifying the character - Oracle aka Barbara Gordon for instance - and including a thumbnail description of them - Formerly Batgirl, now the world's premier infojock and data specialist supreme. I smiled, therefore, when Batman was introduced simply as "Batman aka Bruce Wayne". Less is most definitely more.

For sure there were one or two elements to the story that, for me initially at least, felt somewhat unnecessary and drawn out - the scenes where the two ladies were discovered in the club and had to be escorted to safety come to mind as did the couple of pages where we witnessed Penguin auditioning his staff in the finer points of waiting tables.

That said, I appreciate that such scenes can give the reader a chance to catch one's breath in what was, as I say, an extremely 'hectic' issue. The Penguin scenes also produced one of my favourite panels of artwork in the entire issue from Guillem March - the moment he almost exploded with rage when he felt that his waitress wasn't listening to him was absolutely fantastic: unrecognisable and yet unmistakeably Penguin.

Speaking of the interior art I was surprised to turn the front cover and discover another 'new' artist on this title after last months début from Ardian Syaf. Thankfully, for me anyway, I'm a huge of admirer of Guillem March's style and I enjoyed his work throughout this book - I always feel there a great deal of depth to his art as his figures almost stand-out from the page and this issue was no different. Likewise, I've always appreciated that the artist manages to include so much detail in his panels - on first read through the detail can be almost be incidental sometimes only fully appreciated with a second or third read.

The overall quality of the Birds of Prey series has, in my opinion, suffered as a result of so many changes to the books principle artist although the impact has thankfully been lessened by the quality of the artists involved. That said, I look forward to a time when one artist is able to commit to the series for an extended period of time.

Turning to the books cover, and in many ways I can echo my previous comments regarding the cover of Batgirl #17: the illustration, on this occasion from Stanley 'Artgerm' Lau, is simply fantastic: I love the composition of the montage of Birds of Prey team members - although it's somewhat undermined by Barbara's framing which gives me the impression somewhat that Mr Lau didn't quite know how to include her - but I just can't fully appreciate these very stylized special covers what we're seeing across the Bat-family books this month.

In closing, I thought the final page of this issue - both the sentiment it conveyed and the quality of the illustration - was fantastic and almost worth the cover price alone. All in all, another solid read that's left me puzzling about the story and leaves me wanting more. Highly recommended.

Birds of Prey #8
Written by Gail Simone, art by Guillem March, colours by Nei Ruffino, letters by Travis Lanham, cover art by Stanley 'Artgerm' Lau
Published by DC Comics, March 2011

Guillem March on Gotham City Sirens

DC's The Source this week published a very interesting short interview with artist Guillem March in which he gives an insight into his process when producing the cover for Gotham City Sirens #8.

The issue focuses on Poison Ivy and therefore, not unreasonably, she is the focus of the cover. March talks about the process of creating a number of concept layouts, submitting them for consideration and the technique he used to produce what would turn out to be a quite simply stunning image.

Speaking as someone who doesn't draw or paint I'm aware that I'm sometimes guilty of not appreciating the thought that goes into producing artwork - who'd have thought that using the back of the regular paper stock would have been a consideration? - and I have to say this article was quite an eye-opener for me.

You can read the full article here.

Gotham City Sirens #8 - on sale 27 January 2010

The Sirens' dangerous alliance with The Riddler continues! They're willing to do anything to uncover the truth and protect themselves, but who is the mysterious villain targeting them all for death?

Written by Paul Dini with interior art and cover by Guillem March
DC Comics, 32 pages, $2.99